By 
Selling your car is almost as bad of a decision as moving and finding a new job, basically something people don’t want to think about too hard. There’s paperwork, there’s back-and-forth conversation, there’s the fear of losing money, wasting time, etc. However, the method you choose to sell your car is a bigger deal than people give it credit for, it’s not just about how much money is in your pocket at the end, it’s also about how much headache you’re signing yourself up for in the interim.
People go about this decision in the wrong way. They say, “How much can I get?” when they should instead be asking, “What am I willing to deal with?” Essentially, those two questions are so different from one another that everything going forward from there is influenced by the answer to that first, wrong question.
Therefore, before you consider any options for selling your vehicle, here’s what you should ask yourself:
How Much Time Do You Really Have?
This seems like an obvious question but it’s probably the most honest conversation you need to have with yourself. Selling a car privately can take weeks (or longer). It means getting texts and phone calls at all hours about random inquiries, setting up test drives with strangers where you might encounter either a buyer willing to pay your price or a low-balling person within thirty seconds.
Some cars go fast. Some sit. No one knows what will happen in this realm until they’re in too deep and committed to the process. If you have another vehicle for your use afterward it might be okay – but if you’re selling and already have a replacement in mind, or are trying to do a joint sale and purchase at a dealership, this time pressure element is troubling.
You need to bring your car into the dealership for a trade-in when you want to. You drive it in, they give you an appraisal (hopefully), and if you like the offer, that’s the end of it for you that day. People who work full-time, have families, or just no interest in becoming a part-time vehicle salesperson appreciate this certainty when exploring options; those who want quick and easy value often look into “sell my car” services through a dealership to cut out any sales process that doesn’t work out for them but get their answer immediately.
And it’s not just showings that take time, there’s preparation, cleaning the vehicle, taking pictures, crafting descriptions; then there’s management of postings (should you go private) or deconstruction of the sale (paperwork for title transfer, payments to be made, etc.) after you find a buyer. It’s no joke.
How Much of Stranger Interaction Are You Willing to Tolerate?
This is where it gets personal. Selling your car privately means giving people you’ve never met before access to your home (or meeting them in a parking lot), giving them your car keys with the hope that they’ll at least come back from a test drive with an offer. But then again – maybe not.
For the most part, everything goes fine. But enough people experience mishaps that it’s worth acknowledging. People who hold up the process because they want to talk about their own car-buying history for 45 minutes. People who ghost after showing interest. People who drive and then get back and say, “I need to talk to my spouse” and then make an offer three grand lower than what was warranted.
For some people, this is part of the game; for others, especially if anyone is already anxious or worried about safety, this isn’t discussed enough as a possible dealbreaker when it comes to choosing how best to sell my car.
How Much Paperwork Are You Willing to Encounter?
The paperwork involved with selling your car shocks more people than most things under the sun. There’s title transfer, there’s bill of sale creation (if there are both involved), there’s release of liability papers to fill out (if not handled through a professional buyer), outstanding loans and insurance companies and DMVs need to be notified as well. If someone fills out an appropriate form incorrectly or fails to file something, they’re on the hook for whatever occurs thereafter.
Different methods shift this burden around considerably. For private sales, it’s almost all on you, you’re the person making sure that everything is done right. For dealerships and professional buyers, it’s almost all on them because they process these transactions on a day-to-day basis and have such infrastructure that automatically reduces red tape for each buyer they encounter.
How Good of Condition Is Your Vehicle?
Be honest – not optimistic or hopeful – but honest! Is that check engine light that’s on sometimes just expected wear? That little dent that happened three years ago that you’ve gotten so used to but someone else may notice? The wear-and-tear inside that’s fine for you but potentially going to come out poorly in photographs? It doesn’t make your price any less valuable, or increase it too high if these problems are addressed early on, but selling experience’s levels differ according to selling process type.
Privately, potential buyers will nit-pick every single thing that’s wrong with your vehicle – and assume everything’s wrong with it based on past history, when in reality, they’re just wasting time noting what they believed was wrong versus what actually is due to circumstances beyond your control, but still need to be addressed on price.
Professional buyers will adjust their first lower number more scientifically based on what’s pre-existing or expected issues after extensive experience buying used cars – they might be more likely to give you what you’re looking for, but not within the context of trying to persuade someone where they note little pieces here and there.
Severe problems include high mileage/potential repairs/cosmetic damage are harder for people to sell my car privately without getting serious lower offers; often anyone who’s private selling is turning down serious repairs only mean they’re being far too optimistic about what’s easy and cheap vs time-bending and costly per eye per used car. Serious inquiries dwindle fast.
How Firm Is Your Financial Need?
This relates back to time but deserves consideration as separate for its own merit. If you need X amount of dollars by X date, selling a car privately could go south quickly. You could list at X and although you don’t mind negotiating downward because the asking price is fair. It turns out buyers don’t bite early enough anyway so you could sell it $1K below market value anyway, demanding lower value as critical quality goes against everyone trying out there.
Used vehicle value changes based on factors up until this point, seasonal demands rising/falling, gas prices increasing/decreasing, what’s happening in the new car world changes what’s secondary offered (limited supply), the previous month may have been good for a price but red flags come up yet this month where people aren’t biting due to major issues unforeseen until too late into selling time.
Getting an offer guaranteed today, even if it’s less than what you’re looking for, for potential later-on fees/problems down the line gives most people more comfort than anything else because they know exactly what they’ll be provided without hiccups along the way. For loan payoffs/down payments/budgets to make, it makes sense why cash now is better than cash later.
Are You Willing to Negotiate?
Some people love negotiating; most people don’t mind it. Selling your car privately almost guarantees you’re going to negotiate multiple times with multiple buyers and here’s where it gets uncomfortable, you negotiate from a standpoint that’s already transparent where someone can feel dehumanized.
The longer someone sells their vehicle, and once it’s gone, the more desperate others will assume they’ve become. They price-drop; they leave negotiations feeling icky when they had high hopes initially.
Professional buyers will give you their best offer based on their evaluation; you can accept or deny or see if they counter but there’s typically minimal back-and-forth at play, which for people who don’t have time for games appreciate that direct route through their intention.
What Happens If Something Goes Wrong Down the Line?
This rarely gets asked before something goes wrong, but it should. Selling a used vehicle privately means whatever happens afterward happens as soon as it drives off, even if someone revokes acceptance saying something was broken afterward; even if someone finds an issue you never knew existed; even if buyer’s remorse sets in without cash-back policy fair guidelines bringing up liability.
Legally, private sales are as-is, but that doesn’t mean an unhappy buyer can’t cause problems, disputed charge if used through PayPal or credit card or negative reviews through websites, calls/texts coming down their way trying to bully them back into meeting them half way if there’s something genuinely wrong but without proof, isn’t not okay.
Selling through a dealership or professional buyer means they own whatever happens next, they have the resources, they have assessive means better equipped since they know so much more what they’re doing, and thus legally can run things either which way, but you’re free and clear once payment’s made.
How to Make This Decision that Fits Your Life
Ultimately, there’s no right answer. Some people have the time/energy/patience/personality for private selling and enjoy getting the most out of the vehicles for their efforts and do not mind the headache it brings along with it! Some do! Should have done it all along!
But other people would be better off by methods that prioritize convenience and assured options over looking for every additional dollar along the way, they feel it’s not worth it. The best situation depends entirely on individual circumstances, and includes, but aren’t limited to, the timeline expectations all around; personal comfort levels dealing with owners; financial realities; levels of frustration exemption ratios all play into how much people want feedback from this process compared to how much their lives can afford at this point in time asking it from them.
In short, the best thing anyone can do, before selling, is ask these questions before committing to a seller type instead of halfway through a process that isn’t giving them everything they’re already frustrated enough looking for. Get clean, what do you need from this sale, not just financially but practically, and emotionally. Your car will get sold either way, the question is how much of your life will it be sold through?
Comments